Tags
despair, doubt, faith, fear, God, Jesus, John the Baptist, joy, listen, look, Messiah, Sermon, strong
“Are you the one who is to come, or are we to wait for another?” John the Baptizer’s words have been haunting me all week. This year, John’s question hits a little too close to home. As the safety of people of color has been threatened – whether they are legally or illegally here; as the hard-earned rights of women and those in the LGBTQ+ community are being second-guessed; as the decency of and respect for every human being feels lost as a shared core value, I too find myself asking, “Are you the one who is to come, Jesus, or are we to wait for another?” Where is God in the unraveling of our nation and her communities.[i]
On this third Sunday in Advent – on this Gaudete Sunday, or Rose Sunday, or Joy Sunday – we find no joy in John the Baptizer’s experience. “…Imprisoned for speaking the hard truth to Herod, John is in chains and in crisis, wondering if he has staked his life on the wrong promise and the wrong person. The Messiah, as far as John can tell, has changed nothing. He was supposed to make the world new. He was supposed to bring justice, fairness, and order to human institutions, such that a tyrant like Herod would no longer sit on the throne, and a righteous man like John would no longer languish in a rat-infested prison. Jesus was supposed to finish the costly work John started so boldly in the wilderness — to wield the axe, bring the fire, renew the world.”[ii] And yet, nothing – nothing at all – has worked out as John had imagined from this supposed Messiah.
So how does Jesus answer John’s question? Well, before we go to Jesus’ words in Matthew, we first heard from Isaiah today. You see, John is not the first person of faith to find himself floundering in despair and uncertainty. The prophet Isaiah’s words were consumed by and encouraging to a people in exile – a people who had lost everything and knew not whether they would ever return to their gifted home. To those despondent people, God instructs the prophet Isaiah, saying, “Say to those who are of a fearful heart, ‘Be strong, do not fear! Here is your God.’”[iii] Be strong. Do not fear. Here is your God.
Now you might be thinking, “No offense, Jennifer, but I have been trying for most of this year to be strong and not to fear. And quite frankly, I’m not seeing much of God these days.” You might be feeling like the last year is not so very different from that cold, dank prison cell where John sat – after, let’s be honest, living an exemplary life for God. If a guy who leaps in the womb at the pregnancy of Mary with Jesus, who preaches in the wilderness with minimal resources and rustic living, who baptizes the Messiah himself – if that guy is sitting bewildered about God’s presence in Jesus in the world, how are we supposed to be strong – to not fear – to know that our God is here?
Well, fortunately, Jesus does answer John the Baptizer. Jesus tells the disciples of John to, “Go and tell John what you hear and see: the blind receive their sight, the lame walk, the lepers are cleansed, the deaf hear, the dead are raised, and the poor have good news brought to them. And blessed is anyone who takes no offense at me.”[iv] In other words, scholar Debbie Thomas explains, “Jesus says: go back to John and tell him your stories. Tell him my stories. Tell him what your eyes have seen and your ears have heard. Tell him what only the stories — quiet as they are, scattered as they are, questionable as they are — will reveal. Why? Because who I am is not a pronouncement. Not a sermon, a slogan, or a billboard. Who I am is far more elusive, mysterious, and Other than you have yet imagined. Who I am will emerge in the lives of ordinary people all around you — but only if you’ll consent to see and hear.”[v]
Thomas goes on to say, “But this story is not ‘okay,’ and many of our own stories aren’t okay either. The prison bars that hold us don’t always give way. Our doubts don’t always resolve themselves. Justice doesn’t always arrive in time. Questions don’t always receive the answers we hunger for. Jesus calls us to see and hear all the stories of the kingdom — and that includes John’s story, too. ‘Blessed is anyone who takes no offense at me,’ Jesus says. Offense runs away. Offense quits. Offense erects a wall and hides behind [the wall] because reality is harsher and more complicated than we expected [reality] would be. Yes, some stories are terrible, period. They break hearts and end badly. People flail and people die, and this, too, is what the life of faith looks like. Don’t take offense. Don’t flee.”
Now, I don’t know if you know this, and you may be wondering why we get this part of John’s story today, but John the Baptizer is actually the patron saint of joy. He was in Elizabeth’s womb and leapt for joy at the incarnation of Jesus inside Mary’s womb. According to John’s gospel, when John the Baptizer knew his work was complete and that Jesus the Messiah’s work was beginning, he said, “My joy is now complete.” So how do can we be strong, not fear, and trust that God is here? How can we see and hear Jesus’ stories and embrace joy?
Debie Thomas argues about this, “Maybe John understood something hard and flinty about joy. Joy in a prison cell isn’t about sentimentality. Or happiness. Or the pious suppression of our own most painful crises and questions. Maybe he understood that joy is what happens when we dare to believe that our Messiah disillusions us for nothing less than our salvation, stripping away every lofty expectation we cling to, so that we can know God for who [God] truly is. Maybe [John] realized that God’s work is bigger than the difficult circumstances of his own life, calling John to a selfless joy for the liberation of others. Maybe John’s joy was otherworldly in the most literal sense, because he understood that our stories extend beyond death, and find completion only in the presence of God himself. ‘Are you the one who is coming?’ John asked in despair. ‘You decide,’ Jesus [answers] in love.”[vi]
Nothing we say or do today will whitewash the messiness of these days. No amount of pink or talking or singing about joy is going to transform your heart into joy. What Isaiah and Jesus are saying is that joy can be found though. There are stories and examples of goodness all around you for you to see and hear. Our invitation this week is look and listen – to each other, to our neighbors, to strangers and friend alike. God is around us in the darkness, breaking through with joy. Be strong. Do not fear. God is here. God is here in you, and me, in the stranger, in the other. Our work is to look and listen. Amen.
[i] Karri Alldredge, “Commentary on Matthew 11:2-11,” December 14, 2025, as found at https://www.workingpreacher.org/commentaries/revised-common-lectionary/third-sunday-of-advent/commentary-on-matthew-112-11-7 on December 12, 2025.
[ii] Debie Thomas, “Are You the One?” December 4, 2016 as found at https://journeywithjesus.net/essays/1201-are-you-the-one on December 12, 2025.
[iii] Isaiah 35.4a.
[iv] Matthew 11.4-6.
[v] Thomas.
[vi] Thomas.
